Explore
Journal/The Inability to Let Go

Journal

The Inability to Let Go

Vertigo, The Prestige, Black Swan, The Red Shoes, Phantom Thread — the anatomy of an obsession across five films.

A man is watching a woman.

She must be dead. He knows her grave. He knows her flowers. And yet there she is, standing in front of a florist.

He begins to follow her.

First out of curiosity.

Then out of need.

And after a while, he starts trying to make a living woman resemble a dead one.

The same hair.

The same dress.

The same grey suit.

When I think of *Vertigo*, this is the first scene that comes to mind.

You assume you're about to watch a film about love.

Then you realize it isn't about love at all.

It's about the mark an image leaves on the mind.

Some images aren't forgotten.

Worse, they don't want to be.

And then they slowly begin to reshape the rest of your life in their image.

[bölüm ayracı]

Something strange happened while I was preparing this issue.

At first I was looking for what the films had in common.

After a while they began to bleed into one another.

The streets of San Francisco connected to a rehearsal studio.

A rehearsal studio to a silent dinner table.

As if they were all circling the same thought, yet none of them said the same sentence.

At that point I stopped writing and went for a walk.

Because I couldn't yet put into words what I was feeling.

[bölüm ayracı]

Then another film I've loved for years came to mind.

*The Prestige.*

Two magicians.

Two great tricks.

At first glance, a film about rivalry.

But every time I rewatch it, I stop at the same place.

Past a certain point, no one wants to perform a better illusion anymore.

They just can't accept what the other one can do.

Sometimes a person changes their goal without noticing.

That may be the most dangerous moment.

Because after it, what they're chasing stops being success.

It becomes the thing they can't give up.

[bölüm ayracı]

In a rehearsal studio, a young ballerina repeats the same movement.

Over and over.

From a distance, graceful.

Up close, something else.

Toes crushed inside the shoe.

Calloused feet.

The small marks repetition leaves behind.

*Black Swan* has always caught me most right here.

The film may seem to be about perfection, but every time I see something else.

The memory of a body.

Because the body cannot forget.

A violinist's fingers.

A carpenter's palms.

A dancer's feet.

Years of repetition, after a while, stop being movement.

They settle onto the person.

Maybe that's why mastery has never looked showy to me.

Quite the opposite.

In work done well, the most striking thing is that not a single unnecessary movement remains.

[bölüm ayracı]

Here my mind always goes to the same film.

*The Red Shoes.*

I used to think of these two only as two dance films that had influenced each other.

It doesn't feel that way anymore.

As if one had begun a sentence left unfinished.

And the other completed it decades later.

Some films are not each other's sequels.

They are each other's echoes.

[bölüm ayracı]

Then we enter a quiet house.

A famous couturier is having breakfast.

The smallest sound at the table disturbs the order.

At first glance, discipline.

Look a little longer, control.

That's what I love most about *Phantom Thread*.

That the film isn't much interested in who is right.

We aren't watching two people trying to change each other.

We're watching two people unable to leave each other as they are.

The difference seems small.

It doesn't, once the film ends.

Here I always think of a small moment in *Misery*.

The moment Annie Wilkes takes the typewriter out of the room.

The first time I saw it, I thought it was only to keep him from escaping.

Now it feels like something else.

As if she's locking away not the writer...

but his chance of ever giving up.

Sometimes a person isn't protecting the thing they love.

They're removing its chance to change.

Maybe the quietest obsessions look exactly like this.

[bölüm ayracı]

When I go back to the beginning of this piece, the same man is still walking.

The same woman is still standing in front of the florist.

But now that scene no longer reminds me only of *Vertigo*.

A dancer's foot.

A magician's stubbornness.

A silent breakfast.

Maybe that's why the films in this issue feel so close to one another.

Not because they tell the same story.

Because they stand in the same place.

I suppose a person doesn't change because of what they want most.

They change because of what they can't let go.