Explore
Countries/France

Country room

France

Cinema belongs to the director.

Who does a film belong to?

France never settled it.

Maybe that is why the rest of the world is still asking.


Who does a film belong to?

The one who pays? The one who writes? The one behind the camera? Or if something stays with you after the film ends, does the film belong to whoever made that?

For a long time nobody really argued about it. Cinema was an industry, and the roles were clear: the producer financed, the writer wrote, the actor acted, the director got all the pieces assembled on schedule. A good film was a well-organised film.

Read more

Then a young critic in France broke the arrangement.

In 1954, in Cahiers du cinéma, François Truffaut went after two of the most respected screenwriters of the day, Jean Aurenche and Pierre Bost. His real quarrel was not with two men. It was with the safe cinema they stood for. Films that looked flawless and left no one behind.

For him, what separated one film from another was not its story but the way it looked at the world.

The idea was not Truffaut's. Alexandre Astruc had said a few years earlier that a camera could be used like a pen: the director was not someone who shot images but someone who wrote with them. What Truffaut did was drop that idea into the middle of a fight.

That the fight started in France was no accident. Renoir's warmth, Bresson's silence, Melville's solitude have nothing in common. France never built a shared cinematic language; it built a culture that took the director's own voice seriously. The auteur idea grew in that soil.

Then the interesting part. The writers picked up cameras.

Godard, Chabrol, Rohmer, Rivette. They stopped writing articles and started shooting — no money, in the street, in friends' apartments. Sometimes the light was not enough. Sometimes the sound broke up. Nobody tried to hide it, because for the first time what showed through was not polish but personality.

France never called it a theory. La politique des auteurs: a stance, a preference, and a bit of taking sides.

"Auteur theory" was born on the other side of the ocean. Andrew Sarris carried the idea to America, Pauline Kael stood up against it, and the argument started over. The idea never settled as it spread; everywhere it went it opened a new quarrel. Maybe that was the only way it could stay alive.

We still talk about a director's world. A Bergman film. A Tarkovsky shot. A Wong Kar-wai scene. None of it is an official title; all of it is the echo of one question asked years ago.

Who does a film belong to?

This magazine takes its name from there. There is still no answer — an answer was never what France gave.


The Chain

One film leads to another

  1. L'Atalante · 1934

    L'Atalante

    French cinema learned its first hard lesson here: a film's fate can be taken out of its director's hands.

  2. La Règle du jeu · 1939

    La Règle du jeu

    The film was rejected. Years later it was declared a masterpiece. France's memory for cinema tends to work late.

  3. Children of Paradise · 1945

    Children of Paradise

    The war was over. But in whose name would cinema speak now?

  4. Le Salaire de la peur · 1953

    Le Salaire de la peur

    Clouzot pushed tension to its limit. Someone else would look for the same intensity by removing tension altogether.

  5. Pickpocket · 1959

    Pickpocket

    1959. Bresson subtracted emotion; the same year, someone else broke memory apart.

  6. Hiroshima Mon Amour · 1959

    Hiroshima Mon Amour

    Telling a story was no longer enough. Cinema was looking for the shape of remembering.

  7. The 400 Blows · 1959

    The 400 Blows

    The critic stopped writing. The camera took over.

  8. À bout de souffle · 1960

    À bout de souffle

    For the first time editing stopped being invisible. The audience began to see how a film was made.

  9. Cléo from 5 to 7 · 1962

    Cléo from 5 to 7

    And there's this: inside the same movement there was a completely different way of looking.

  10. The Umbrellas of Cherbourg · 1964

    The Umbrellas of Cherbourg

    Reality breaks sometimes through color, sometimes through silence. France allowed both at once.

  11. Le Samouraï · 1967

    Le Samouraï

    Melville built a style by taking away. Tati went looking for order inside excess.

  12. Playtime · 1967

    Playtime

    Tati spent everything he had to build that city. The film never returned it, and it ruined him.

  13. My Night at Maud's · 1969

    My Night at Maud's

    Twenty-six years pass here. This selection skips them, because the real rupture came later and it sounded nothing like this.

  14. La Haine · 1995

    La Haine

    This time the point wasn't to portray France, but to show who France wasn't seeing.

  15. Beau Travail · 2000

    Beau Travail

    The gaze had turned to the body. The next generation would question the gaze itself.

  16. Portrait of a Lady on Fire · 2019

    Portrait of a Lady on Fire

    And the question came back to where it started. Who is looking, who is being looked at — and who owns the film?

Veins

How a country's cinema changed direction, and with whom.

Entering the sound era, France found its heroes on docks and in rented rooms.

They refused the postwar order: one threw out acting, another never let his hero speak.

The New Wave was not a programme; it was a few friends who wrote in a magazine for years.

On the left bank of Paris there was another group, arriving from literature and documentary.

The exuberance of the sixties ended, French cinema went home and did not like what it found.

In the same decade, the most ornate Paris and the northern towns shot with amateurs.

A record of the films that went out into the world as France; not a ranking of quality.

Films whose protagonist is not human: a meadow, a migration route, a field of ice.

French cinema today does not run in one direction; all it shares is that the director still decides.


Today

All of this was shot in the last few years. To see how we got here, you have to go back ninety years.