Explore
Countries/Italy

Country room

Italy

Italy turned looking into a moral question.

Is filming poverty the same as seeing it?

The camera went into the street out of necessity.

It never quite came back inside.


In Italy, cinema was never only cinema.

When the war ended, nothing was being shot at Cinecittà. People who had lost their homes were living in the studios. The camera went out into the street. Because there was nowhere else to go. The manifesto was written later.

Rossellini filmed Rome while the wounds were still open. The city wasn't a set; it was the film itself.

A few years later Cesare Zavattini went further. He said there was no need to look for big stories. Following one person was enough. For ninety minutes. If you really knew how to look, life was already writing the story.

De Sica tried it.

In Bicycle Thieves the lead wasn't a professional actor but an actual factory worker.

The point wasn't to look more real.

Read more

It was to let a real life walk in front of the camera.

But there's a small paradox here.

Most of the Italian films we call "realist" didn't record their sound on set. The dialogue was spoken again later, in a studio.

In a way, the cinema that looked most real was using one of the most artificial tools there is.

Maybe realism was never a technical matter.

The objection didn't come from aesthetics either.

In 1952 a government minister was furious about De Sica's Umberto D.

Why show the country's poverty to the whole world?

The argument wasn't about how the film was made.

It was about who has the right to be seen.

Neorealism didn't last long.

But the directors looking at the same streets didn't make the same films.

Fellini slowly turned Rome into a dream.

Antonioni became interested in the silences where people lose one another.

Same country. Same cities. Completely different eyes.

Italy's influence didn't stop there either.

In Calcutta a young graphic designer watched Bicycle Thieves. His name was Satyajit Ray.

He went home and began telling the story of his own village.

Similar journeys followed in Tehran, in Havana, in Dakar.

Italy didn't teach the world how to film poverty.

It left behind a harder question.

Is turning a camera toward a person really the same as seeing them?


The Chain

One film leads to another

  1. Ossessione · 1943

    Ossessione

    Italian cinema began inside the war. Fascist censors banned this film and destroyed the negative; Visconti had hidden a copy.

  2. Rome, Open City · 1945

    Rome, Open City

    No sets, no lights, no money. The city itself became the décor, and the world gave it a name.

  3. Bicycle Thieves · 1948

    Bicycle Thieves

    A bicycle, a father, a son. This is where the world learned how much can be said with so little.

  4. La strada · 1954

    La strada

    Fellini came out of neorealism and turned towards dream without leaving the street. The same pavement, a different light.

  5. L'avventura · 1960

    L'avventura

    It was booed at Cannes. A woman disappears, the film stops looking for her, and leaves the audience in that gap.

  6. Divorzio all'italiana · 1961

    Divorzio all'italiana

    Italy argues its heaviest questions by laughing. A law once softened murder; the film mocked it, and the law fell years later.

  7. Il posto · 1961

    Il posto

    The laughter stops and the camera enters the office. Olmi films the job won not as a victory but as a door closing.

  8. Salvatore Giuliano · 1962

    Salvatore Giuliano

    Rosi founded a genre here: the inquiry film without an answer. The crime is plain, the culprit is not, and the film does not hide it.

  9. Il vangelo secondo Matteo · 1964

    Il vangelo secondo Matteo

    The man who filmed the Gospel was a Marxist, and Catholic circles praised the result. Such things happen in Italy.

  10. The Good, the Bad and the Ugly · 1966

    The Good, the Bad and the Ugly

    In those same years Italy filmed America's myth better than America. Shot in Spain, dubbed afterwards, sold to the world as a western.

  11. The Battle of Algiers · 1966

    The Battle of Algiers

    This time the camera looked not at Italy but at a colony. It seems so real that they had to open it with a notice: no documentary footage was used.

  12. Il conformista · 1970

    Il conformista

    The morality of looking passed into form itself. Light, shadow and framing tell the story of a man's surrender.

  13. Suspiria · 1977

    Suspiria

    And Italy also did the exact opposite. Colour, sound, dread; nothing of realism is left — and yet it is still an Italian film.

  14. Cinema Paradiso · 1988

    Cinema Paradiso

    In the eighties the cinemas began to close. Italy sang a lament for its own cinema, and the world wept at it.

  15. Gomorrah · 2008

    Gomorrah

    Then the camera went back into the street. Sixty years had passed and the question had not changed at all.

  16. Happy as Lazzaro · 2018

    Happy as Lazzaro

    Italy never found the answer. But it reminded us once more that turning a camera on someone is not innocent — this time with a fable.

Veins

How a country's cinema changed direction, and with whom.

As the war ended nothing was being shot in the studio; people who had lost their homes lived there.

Once the street had been told, the camera turned inward: one to dream, the other to emptiness.

Italians argued their heaviest questions by laughing; someone always got hurt in the end.

Unable to answer who really runs the country, cinema made the investigation itself the film.

In a Catholic country the directors neither rejected nor accepted the sacred; they argued with it.

The American western was shot in Spain, dubbed afterwards and sold to the world.

The films the world thinks of as Italy; some describe Italy, others the Italy people wanted.

Italian cinema today is not at peace with its past, and that is a good thing.


Today

All of this was shot in recent years. To see how we got here, you have to go back eighty years.